Skip Nav
Thanksgiving Holiday In observance of Thanksgiving, all State of Nevada offices will be closed on Thursday, November 26, and Friday, November 27, 2026. Thank you! State Holidays

Commission Decisions

Decisions of the Nevada Commission on Judicial Discipline

2026 Decisions

Erika Ballou - Case Nos. 2025-041-P & 2025-156-P
05/06/2026 - In the Matter of the Honorable Erika Ballou, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Immediate Resignation and Permanent Bar from Judicial Office

Michele Fiore - Case No. 2025-108-P
04/24/2026 - In the Matter of the Honorable Michele Fiore, Justice of the Peace, Pahrump Township Justice Court, Nye County, State of Nevada, Formal Statement of Charges (See "Public Proceedings" page for additional information as it becomes available)

Max Bunch - Case No. 2024-224-P
04/01/2026 - In the Matter of the Honorable Max Bunch, Senior Judge, Union Township Justice Court, Humboldt County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

2025 Decisions

Erika Ballou - Case Nos. 2024-103-P & 2024-105-P
09/22/2025 - In the Matter of the Honorable Erika Ballou, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

Michele Fiore - Case Nos. 2024-ADM-02 & 2025-108

In the Matter of the Honorable Michele Fiore, Justice of the Peace, Pahrump Township Justice Court, Nye County, State of Nevada

Gary Fairman - Case No. 2023-155-P
04/15/2025 - In the Matter of the Honorable Gary Fairman, District Court Judge, Seventh Judicial District Court, Eureka County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

James Davis - Case No. 2024-031-P
02/04/2025 - In the Matter of the Honorable James Davis, Hearing Master, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Admonishment

2024 Decisions

Michele Fiore - Case No. 2024-ADM-02

07/24/2024 - In the Matter of the Honorable Michele Fiore, Justice of the Peace, Pahrump Township Justice Court, Nye County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Order Suspending Respondent from the Exercise of Judicial Office With Salary

Mary Perry - Case Nos. 2022-062-P & 2023-039-P
07/18/2024 - In the Matter of the Honorable Mary Perry, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Censure

Jim Loveless - Case No. 2023-100-P
06/24/2024 - In the Matter of the Honorable Jim Loveless, Justice of the Peace, Union Township Justice Court, Humboldt County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand 

Erika Ballou - Case Nos. 2022-124-P, 2022-134-P and 2022-173-P
06/11/2024 - In the Matter of the Honorable Erika Ballou, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Censure

Michele Mercer- Case Nos. 2023-002-P and 2023-127-P
05/30/2024 - In the Matter of the Honorable Michele Mercer, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

2023 Decisions

Elias Goicoechea- Case No. 2022-028-P
12/22/2023 - In the Matter of the Honorable Elias Goicoechea, Former Justice of the Peace, Elko Justice Court, Elko County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

Nancy Saitta- Case No. 2023-035-P
12/20/2023 - In the Matter of the Honorable Nancy Saitta, Senior Judge, Second Judicial District Court, Washoe County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand and Agreement to Not Apply for or Accept Any Appointment as Senior Judge

Nadin Cutter - Case Nos. 2022-004-P & 2022-036-P
07/19/2023 - In the Matter of the Honorable Nadin Cutter, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

2022 Decisions

Kathleen Delaney - Case Nos. 2021-025-P & 2022-026-P
12/21/2022 - In the Matter of the Honorable Kathleen Delaney, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Adam Vander Heyden - Case No. 2021-143-P
12/13/2022 - In the Matter of Adam Vander Heyden, Pro Tem Judge, Las Vegas Justice Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Douglas E. Smith - Case No. 2022-027-P

11/15/2022 - In the Matter of the Honorable Douglas E. Smith, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Bar From Serving in a Judicial Office in the Future

Nancy Saitta - Case No. 2020-081-P
08/01/2022 - In the Matter of the Honorable Nancy Saitta, Senior Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

2021 Decisions

Amy Chelini - Case No. 2019-091-P
08/13/2021 - In the Matter of the Honorable Amy Chelini, Justice of the Peace, Las Vegas Justice Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Melanie Andress-Tobiasson - Case Nos. 2018-120-P, 2019-005-P and 2019-090
04/29/2021 - In the Matter of the Honorable Melanie Andress-Tobiasson, Justice of the Peace, Las Vegas Justice Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Resignation and Resolution of All Pending Matters Involving Commission and Respondent

Richard Scotti - Case No. 2019-183-P
03/15/2021 - In the Matter of the Honorable Richard Scotti, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Kerry Earley - Case No. 2019-040-P
01/21/2021 - In the Matter of the Honorable Kerry Earley, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Admonishment

2020 Decisions

William S. Potter – Case No. 2019-182-P
09/30/2020 - In the Matter of the Honorable William S. Potter, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Admonishment

2019 Decisions

Melanie Andress-Tobiasson & Amy Chelini - Case Nos. 2019-090 & 2019-091
12/24/2019 - In the Consolidated Matter of the Honorable Melanie Andress-Tobiasson and Amy Chelini, Justices of the Peace, Las Vegas Justice Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Order Continuing Commission Investigations

Jennifer Henry - Case No. 2016-142-P
12/12/19 - In the Matter of the Honorable Jennifer Henry, Hearing Master, Eighth Judicial District Court, Family Division, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

Kent Jasperson - Case No. 2018-053-P
07/23/2019 - In the Matter of the Honorable Kent Jasperson, Pahrump Township Justice Court, Nye County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Martin Hastings - Case No. 2017-119-P

03/06/2019 - In the Matter of the Honorable Martin Hastings, Municipal Court Judge, Las Vegas Municipal Court, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

David Humke - Case No. 2018-186-P
01/14/2019 - In the Matter of the Honorable David Humke, District Court Judge, Second Judicial District Court, Washoe County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Discipline

2018 Decisions

David Humke - Case No. 2018-186
11/02/2018 - In the Matter of the Honorable David Humke, District Court Judge, Second Judicial District Court, Washoe County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Order of Interim Suspension

Heidi Almase - Case No. 2017-099-P
10/22/2018 - In the Matter of Heidi Almase, Former Municipal Court Judge, City of Las Vegas, Clark County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

Charles Weller - Case No. 2017-025-P
09/20/2018 - In the Matter of the Honorable Charles Weller, District Court Judge, Second Judicial District Court, Washoe County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

Douglas E. Smith - Case No. 2016-068-P
07/27/2018 - In the Matter of the Honorable Douglas E. Smith, Eighth Judicial District Court, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Discipline

Rena G. Hughes - Case No. 2016-113-P
06/18/2018 - In the Matter of the Honorable Rena G. Hughes, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

David Humke - Case No. 2016-150-P
06/11/2018 - In the Matter of the Honorable David Humke, District Court Judge, Second Judicial District Court, Washoe County, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Discipline

Jay T. Gunter - Case No. 2017-053-P
05/18/2018 - In the Matter of the Honorable Jay T. Gunter, Justice of the Peace, Hawthorne Township Justice Court, County of Mineral, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Censure and Agreement to Complete a National Judicial College Course

William Gus Sullivan - Case No. 2017-009-P
02/26/2018 - In the Matter of the Honorable William Gus Sullivan, Pahrump Township Justice Court, County of Nye, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

2017 Decisions

William S. Potter – Case No. 2015-013-P
11/22/2017 - In the Matter of the Honorable William S. Potter, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

William Kephart - Case No. 2016-41-P
08/31/2017 - In the Matter of the Honorable William Kephart, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Dawn Haviland - Case No. 2016-078-P
08/29/2017 - In the Matter of the Honorable Dawn Haviland, Goodsprings Township Justice Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

Conrad Hafen - Case Nos. 2016-070, 071, 072 and 076
02/27/2017 - In the Matter of Conrad Hafen, Former Justice of the Peace, City of Las Vegas, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Censure and Agreement Not to Serve in a Judicial Position

Douglas E. Smith - Case No. 2015-032-P
02/27/2017 - In the Matter of the Honorable Douglas E. Smith, Eighth Judicial District Court, Department 8, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Melanie Andress-Tobiasson - Case No. 2014-094-P
02/23/2017 - In the Matter of the Honorable Melanie Andress-Tobiasson, Justice of the Peace, Las Vegas Township, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

2016 Decisions

Dawn Haviland - Case Nos. 2016-078, 079 & 080
12/28/2016 - In the Matter of the Honorable Dawn Haviland, Justice of the Peace, Goodsprings Township, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Order Suspending Respondent From the Exercise of Judicial Office With Salary

Sylvia Beller - Case No. 2015-057
08/23/2016 - In the Matter of the Honorable Sylvia Beller, Hearing Master, Eighth Judicial District Court, Family Division, County of Clark, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Sean Hoeffgen - Case No. 2014-122-P
08/23/2016 - In the Matter of the Honorable Sean Hoeffgen, Municipal Court Judge, City of North Las Vegas, County of Clark, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Michael Kalleres - Case No. 2014-110-P
08/23/2016 - In the Matter of Honorable Michael Kalleres, Municipal Court Judge, City of Ely, County of White Pine, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Catherine Ramsey - Case No. 2014-093-P
08/23/2016 - In the Matter of the Honorable Catherine Ramsey, Municipal Court Judge, City of North Las Vegas, County of Clark, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Discipline

Dawn Haviland - Case No. 1502-137
04/25/2016 - In the Matter of the Honorable Dawn Haviland, Goodsprings Township Justice of the Peace, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Ron Kent – Case No. 2015-003
03/16/16 - In the Matter of the Honorable Ron Kent, Pahrump Justice of the Peace, County of Nye, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Consent Order for Resignation

Kimberly Wanker - Case No. 1501-1147
03/03/16 - In the Matter of the Honorable Kimberly Wanker, Fifth Judicial District Court, Dept. One, County of Nye, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand

Steven E. Jones - Case No. 2006-100
03/01/2016 - In the Matter of Steven E. Jones, Certified Copy of Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

Michael Fletcher - Case No. 1504-092
02/17/16 - In the Matter of the Honorable Michael Fletcher, Walker River Township Justice of the Peace, County of Lyon, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order of Consent to Public Reprimand 

2015 Decisions

Michelle Leavitt - Case No. 2012-112
05/13/15 - In the Matter of the Honorable Michelle Leavitt, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Certified Copy of Stipulation and Order for Public Reprimand

2014 Decisions

Michael Fletcher - Case No. 2013-010
09/16/14 - In the Matter of the Honorable Michael Fletcher, Walker River Justice of the Peace, County of Lyon, State of Nevada, Stipulation and Order for Public Reprimand

Steven E. Jones - Case No. 1206-218
02/03/14 - In the Matter of the Honorable Steven Jones, District Court Judge, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

2013 Decisions

Valorie Vega - Case No. 1203-324
08/29/13 - In the Matter of the Honorable Valorie Vega, District Court Judge, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order Imposing Discipline

Daniel Bauer - Case No. 1205-1048
07/12/13 - In the Matter of the Honorable Daniel Bauer, Former Municipal Court Judge, Fernley Municipal Court, County of Lyon, State of Nevada, Stipulation and Order for Public Reprimand

Terry Graham - Case No. 1202-1083
05/17/13 - In the Matter of the Honorable Terry Graham, Justice of the Peace, Wadsworth Justice Court, County of Washoe, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

2012 Decisions

Steven E. Jones - Case No. 1204-218
11/29/12 - In the Matter of the Honorable Steven E. Jones, District Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Order Suspending Respondent From the Exercise of Judicial Office With Salary

Reese F. Melville - Case No. 1201-1133
04/16/12 - In the Matter of the Honorable Reese F. Melville, Justice of the Peace, Eastline Township Justice Court, County of Elko, State of Nevada, Amended Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Consent Order Imposing Discipline

2011 Decisions

James En Earl - Case No. 1102-254
07/01/11 - In the Matter of the Honorable James En Earl, Retired Justice of the Peace, East Fork Justice Court, County of Douglas, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Consent Order Imposing Discipline

Anthony Abbatangelo - Case No. 1101-219
03/30/11 - In the Matter of the Honorable Anthony Abbatangelo, Former Justice of the Peace, Las Vegas Township Justice Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Consent Order Imposing Discipline

2008 Decisions

Elizabeth Halverson - Case No. 0801-1066
11/17/08 - In the Matter of the Honorable Elizabeth Halverson, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline (Filed November 17, 2008) Appellate Opinion: (Unpublished) Available on Supreme Court Website

Nicholas Del Vecchio - Case No. 0802-1008
11/06/08 - In the Matter of the Honorable Nicholas Del Vecchio, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

Lee A Gates - Case No. 0701-260
07/07/08 - In the Matter of the Honorable Lee A. Gates, District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

2007 Decisions

George Assad - Case No. 0602-1034
02/08/07 - In the Matter of the Honorable George Assad, Municipal Court Judge, City of Las Vegas, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline
Appellate Opinion: Matter of Assad, 124 Nev. 391, 185 P.3d 1044 ( 2008)

2006 Decisions

Michael Memeo - Case No. 0601-989
12/26/06 - In the Matter of the Honorable Michael Memeo, District Judge, Fourth Judicial District Court, County of Elko, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order

Kevin Higgins - Case No. 0603-1033
12/04/06 - In the Matter of the Honorable Kevin Higgins, Justice of the Peace, Sparks Township, County of Washoe, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order

Sylvia Beller - Case No. 0503-977
07/31/06 - In the Matter of the Honorable Sylvia Beller, Hearing Master, Family Court & Services Center, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline

Daniel Ward - Case No. 0502-247
02/03/06 - In the Matter of the Honorable Daniel Ward, Justice of the Peace, New River Township Justice Court, County of Churchill, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline

2005 Decisions

Jeffrey Sobel - Case No. 0405-248 Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline 01
08/15/05 - In the Matter of the Honorable Jeffrey Sobel, Former District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline (As Amended 8/15/05)

Jeffrey Sobel - Case No. 0405-248 Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline 02
08/15/05 - In the Matter of the Honorable Jeffrey Sobel, Former District Court Judge, Eighth Judicial District, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline

Peter LaPorta - Case No. 0401-1016 & 0402-1016
07/14/05 - In the Matter of the Honorable Peter LaPorta, Judge Pro Tempore, Henderson Municipal Court and Henderson Justice Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Order

Charles M. McGee - Case No. 0501-185
01/10/2005 - In the Matter of the Honorable Charles M. McGee, District Judge, Second Judicial District Court, County of Washoe, State of Nevada, Stipulation - Public Censure; Public Censure Letter

2004 Decisions

Phillip Thomas - Case No. 0403-264
10/07/04 - In the Matter of the Honorable Philip Thomas; Justice of the Peace, Gerlach Township Justice Court, County of Washoe, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Imposition of Discipline and Consent Order

Paul Freitag - Case No. 0404-228
10/07/04 - In the Matter of the Honorable Paul Freitag; Former Justice of the Peace, Sparks Township Justice Court, County of Washoe, State of Nevada, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Imposition of Discipline and Consent Order

Peter LaPorta - Case No. 0401-1016
06/24/04 - In the Matter of Honorable Peter LaPorta, Judge Pro Tempore, Henderson Municipal Court and Henderson Justice Court, County of Clark, State of Nevada, Respondent. Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

2003 Decisions

James EnEarl - Case No. 0301-254
09/18/03 - In the Matter of the Honorable James EnEarl; Finding of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Imposition of Discipline

2002 Decisions

Donald M. Mosley - Case No. 0001-110
03/12/02 - In the Matter of the Honorable Donald M. Mosley, Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline
Appellate Opinion: Mosley v. Nevada Commission on Judicial Discipline, 102 P.3d 555, 560 (2004).

2000 Decisions

Brian Morrison - Case No. 9902-258
05/04/00 - In the Matter of the Brian Morrison; Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Imposition of Discipline

Laura Ungaro - Case No. 9901-955
05/04/00 - In the Matter of the Laura Ungaro; Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Imposition of Discipline

1999 Decisions

Douglas E. Smith - Case No. 9804-255
05/04/99 - In the Matter of the Honorable Douglas E. Smith; Decision and Order

1998 Decisions

Steven E. Jones - Case No. 9803-218 & 9805-218
12/30/98 - In the Matter of the Honorable Steven E. Jones; Order

Gloria S. Sanchez - Case No. 9801-217
10/26/98 - In the Matter of the Honorable Gloria S. Sanchez; Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Imposition of Discipline

Frances-Ann Fine - Case No. 9802-222 Decision to Impose Discipline
10/21/98 - In the Matter of the Honorable Frances-Ann Fine; Decision to Impose Discipline (1998)
Appellate Opinion: Matter of Fine, 116 Nev. 1001, 13 P.3d 400 (2000)

Frances-Ann Fine - Case No. 9802-222 Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order (1998)
10/06/98 - In the Matter of the Honorable Frances-Ann Fine; Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order (1998)
Appellate Opinion: Matter of Fine, 116 Nev. 1001, 13 P.3d 400 (2000).

1997 Decisions

Terrance P. Marren - Case No. 9702-215
07/10/97 - In the Matter of the Honorable Terrance P. Marren; Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Imposition of Discipline (1997)

1995 Decisions

Frances-Ann Fine - Case No. 9501-222 Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline
11/14/95 - In the Matter of the Honorable Frances-Ann Fine; Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Imposition of Discipline

Frances-Ann Fine - Case No. 9501-222 Dissent to the Majority's Imposition of Discipline
11/14/95 - In the Matter of the Honorable Frances-Ann Fine; Dissent to the Majority's Imposition of Discipline

Gary Davis - Case No. 9502-107
12/95 - In the Matter of the Honorable Gary Davis
Appellate Opinion: Matter of Davis, 113 Nev. 1204, 946 P.2d 1033 (1997).

1992 Decisions

In the Matter of the Honorable Paul Goldman [Decision unavailable.]
Appellate Opinion: Matter of Goldman, 108 Nev. 251, 830 P.2d 107